Skip to main content

Oral History Project

< Back

Prof. O. Prabhakar in conversation with Prof. B.S. Murty

00:00:11

Good morning friends.

00:00:13

Welcome to this interaction session with Professor O. Prabhakar,

00:00:17

with the Heritage Centre.

00:00:18

Professor Prabhakar, thank you, sir,

00:00:20

thanks for coming

00:00:21

and to spare your valuable time with us.

00:00:25

You had a very distinguished,

00:00:27

I would say, honour

00:00:33

of becoming a faculty in the same place

00:00:35

where you had your graduate studies and also PhD studies.

00:00:39

Shall we go to your undergraduate studies level

00:00:43

and to know what motivated you to join IIT Madras?

00:00:47

What was the perception of students those days,

00:00:50

school students about IITs;

00:00:52

can we start with that?

00:00:54

Thank you, Professor Murty,

00:00:56

senior professors, Professor Swamy,

00:00:59

Professor Reddy, I am very happy they are here.

00:01:03

Yes, I have the distinction in some way,

00:01:08

of being associated with IIT for a very long time.

00:01:13

I joined here in 1960,

00:01:15

and probably went out in 1998,

00:01:19

and in fact, one of the directors called me

00:01:22

a good example of inbreeding.

00:01:25

But anyway, there stands the matter.

00:01:29

Yes, we all...that time, IIT was not very popular.

00:01:33

In fact, the there was no examination.

00:01:36

It was recruitment by our marks in

00:01:40

Plus 2. final plus 2 and...

00:01:43

Was plus 2 there, sir, those days? We were fortunate.

00:01:45

It was called plus 2, what was it?

00:01:47

Pre-University it was called. Pre-University, okay, sir.

00:01:49

And, we had one oral examination,

00:01:52

Okay. where all Germans were sitting and evaluating us.

00:01:55

And, there was no written exam, it started much later.

00:02:00

But, the oral was technical, about science? Purely technical,

00:02:03

all creative. In fact, very very creative. Very, very. Very good

00:02:06

Very good. It used to be demonstrative,

00:02:08

not even talking.

00:02:10

And, I like that. Oral exam was very good.

00:02:14

To know your interest in science particularly,

00:02:16

possibly, that was very good.

00:02:18

And, I came because, I came number 1 or 2,

00:02:22

I don't know exactly, in Madura college.

00:02:24

So, the principal, Prof. Totadri Iyengar,

00:02:29

he called me to his room and

00:02:30

said, "there is a very good institute in IIT,

00:02:33

called IIT in Chennai, why don't you apply?"

00:02:35

We all thought of only Guindy Engineering College,

00:02:38

that was our ultimate. True, true, true.

00:02:40

Incidentally, I got admitted there also. Okay.

00:02:43

And, he said, "why don't you go there?"

00:02:46

and that's the first time I heard.

00:02:48

My father was not impressed.

00:02:50

For him, it is Guindy College,

00:02:54

go to Guindy College.

00:02:56

but then, So, a whole decision on your part.

00:02:59

I took the lead,

00:03:01

Yeah. I convinced him that when my principal says,

00:03:04

Okay. there must be something very good.

00:03:06

Okay. But, I don't regret the decision.

00:03:08

Wonderful. Thank you sir. It was

00:03:10

a fantastic journey after we joined.

00:03:13

And, it was the very very

00:03:17

beginning period in IIT, that time.

00:03:20

Yeah, yeah, I know you were the second batch. Second batch.

00:03:24

And... You also said, I think, if I remember right,

00:03:27

first batch in the hostels, you said. Yeah. Correct!

00:03:30

It was Krishna hostel.

00:03:32

We had only one floor,

00:03:34

ground floor constructed,

00:03:35

with all brick and mortar scale. That was the only one hostel those days, possibly.

00:03:38

Yes, yes.

00:03:40

And 100 yards from my room,

00:03:42

I was in the last room - F12,

00:03:45

there was a burning ghat,

00:03:48

people used to be burning dead bodies..

00:03:51

and just about. On the campus?

00:03:52

On the campus, just about 100 metres.. Okay.

00:03:56

And later, the director intervened, banned and all that. Okay.

00:04:01

And, students used to be afraid of sleeping in their room.

00:04:04

I can understand. He was a very, very fine, Professor Chaudhri,

00:04:06

was our warden.

00:04:08

There were some of the students,

00:04:09

who were scared of ghosts and pisaasu,

00:04:11

and, all that,

00:04:13

they used to go to his room and sleep. Okay, okay.

00:04:16

And, in fact, one of the students was even termed as Ghost.

00:04:19

He is still popularly known as Ghost.

00:04:21

Because, he was so afraid of ghosts. So, Okay.

00:04:25

This is the thing. Okay.

00:04:28

And, this one I will come later, I will show you some...

00:04:33

First when we entered,

00:04:35

there was no dining table in the room.

00:04:38

In the dining hall. Okay.

00:04:39

We all sat on the floor and ate food. floor.

00:04:42

Maybe, they all thought that it's good

00:04:44

for your health, you know.

00:04:48

Nowadays, it's very difficult to find people

00:04:50

Yes. who can sit down and eat, right.

00:04:52

A burning ghat was there.

00:04:54

Okay. Believe me,

00:04:55

through the night they used to bring dead bodies and burn,

00:04:58

and used to be a heavy

00:05:00

But, I heard this was a jungle, right, sir? smell.

00:05:02

How people will... Well, for Velachery doors are open,

00:05:05

that time. Oh, Velachery

00:05:06

side was open. It is their regular burial ground.,

00:05:08

Okay, okay. Later, IIT, I think, took action to stop it

00:05:12

and it became part of our grounds.

00:05:16

Krishna was only on the ground floor.

00:05:19

We were the first batch to officially enter IIT.

00:05:23

That is why Professor Sengupto

00:05:25

had a very soft corner for us.

00:05:27

Okay. Because, we withstood a lot of difficulties.

00:05:31

We used to be taken like cattle,

00:05:33

like cattle in a truck

00:05:36

to college, to classrooms in CLRI,

00:05:39

there were no classroom here. Okay.

00:05:42

Like cattle, I am not joking at all.

00:05:43

We used to stand and

00:05:48

used to be taken literally, like cattle,

00:05:50

we used to be taken.

00:05:52

People will be falling

00:05:53

because, there were no good road, right...

00:05:55

used to be falling and...

00:05:58

So, there were no IIT buses those days?

00:06:00

Nothing. Only N. T. Rama Rao

00:06:02

will come in his chariot

00:06:04

and there will be cinema shooting taking place, Oh

00:06:08

In the campus? Oh, Okay. Campus.

00:06:09

because of forest atmosphere. Okay, okay.

00:06:12

And, this is the Krishna where we stayed first, this is Cauvery.

00:06:16

Later, I went on to become warden also there.

00:06:20

And, Professor Chaudhri was a

00:06:24

very kind man; he was just like a fatherly figure.

00:06:29

He took care of us. wWater flooding used to take place,

00:06:32

water will come into the room

00:06:34

in the monsoon time. It happens even now, sir, once a while.

00:06:36

Holi, was for me, it is a novel experience,

00:06:39

we were all ducked in...

00:06:40

our north Indian friends used to be very exuberant. Yeah.

00:06:44

So, when I am bit shy or withdrawing,

00:06:46

they will definitely chase me. Yeah, yeah, they will.

00:06:49

So, they have a...they have a prey there, Prey.

00:06:52

right? If you by yourself go to a water,

00:06:54

they are not so much, right. True, true, true.

00:06:57

Ragging was very minimal,

00:07:00

though some students

00:07:01

were I remember dismissed...our juniors,

00:07:05

three of them, for doing extremes of ragging.

00:07:08

Some four or 5five students were dismissed,

00:07:10

that I know very well.

00:07:11

Yeah, now we don't even hear about that. Even at my time,

00:07:14

that was...there was more friendliness rather than ragging. Yeah,

00:07:16

true, true. That is good. And,

00:07:19

these are the hostel.

00:07:21

4.5 years we stayed in Cauvery,

00:07:23

0.5 we stayed in Krishna.

00:07:26

And, we have to walk, there was no tarred road.

00:07:32

It was a kachha road there, will be full of thorns,

00:07:36

and imagine, your cycle gets punctured

00:07:39

and you have a bag, night, water,

00:07:42

no light, we have to walk through.

00:07:45

In the dark. dark.

00:07:46

That is why, Professor Sengupto

00:07:49

was really kind to us, whatever we ask, he will give.

00:07:53

Because, we did not complain.

00:07:56

We put up with the trouble,

00:07:58

I won't say trouble,

00:08:00

some inconveniences Inconveniences.

00:08:01

in a very gamely way; nobody used to complain, Correct, correct.

00:08:04

people used to be happy. Correct.

00:08:06

And, NTR movies used to be filmed,

00:08:10

I am not joking.

00:08:11

The fellow will go on a chariot,

00:08:13

and singing song, because of the forest atmosphere, right.

00:08:18

And, this is about general,

00:08:21

Okay, okay. our undergraduate

00:08:23

Good, good, good. beginning.

00:08:24

Anything about your academics? Full of...it was swarming with Germans.

00:08:29

Where there any Indian faculty

00:08:31

those days, in the department? Yes, yes we

00:08:32

were very fortunate because,

00:08:35

senior faculty used to take our classes.

00:08:38

They didn't have research. Okay.

00:08:40

Very, very senior - Professor Ramasastry,

00:08:43

Aravavamudhan.

00:08:47

Professor S. K. Srinivasan, of mathematics. You should be

00:08:51

very, very fortunate to hear their lectures.

00:08:53

We were very fortunate because

00:08:56

senior people were coming, E. G. Ramachandran,

00:08:59

where they didn't have much to do,

00:09:01

so, they took our classes.

00:09:03

Okay. And, that way we were extremely benefited.

00:09:06

Many of our classes were taken by Germans. Okay.

00:09:09

For example, physics, Professor Koch took it.

00:09:12

Yeah, professor was eventually, Professor Reddy was... Maths, Professor Hahn, took math.

00:09:17

He used to give grade like d to the power of minus 6 tending to 0,

00:09:22

limit tending to 0, right.

00:09:25

Okay. It was very unique experience.

00:09:28

next, go ahead. You had this common courses

00:09:31

only for 1 year or extending into the 2nd and

00:09:34

3rd years? Up to two and half years.

00:09:36

Up to two and half We had a 5 year course.

00:09:37

Okay. So, up to two and half every student of every branch, Yes.

00:09:40

goes through the same curriculum. Same.

00:09:42

eEngineering background. So, two

00:09:43

and half years is what you would study

00:09:45

your departmental subjects, is it like that? Oh, yeah.

00:09:48

More or less. Even in the other two and half,

00:09:51

some parts we study, professors from

00:09:54

chemical engineering took our classes, Okay, okay.

00:09:56

electrical engineering took our classes. Classes.

00:09:59

and Good, good, good, good.

00:10:01

some common classes were there. Oh, okay, sir.

00:10:03

Much more of, I think, general engineering. We did physics,

00:10:06

Professor Ramasastry told me in person,

00:10:10

"I have taught whatever that could be

00:10:12

taught for an MSc Physics,

00:10:14

I do not know what else to teach you people."

00:10:17

Is exactly what he told.

00:10:18

He was also a very good teacher. Things have significantly

00:10:21

changed in all, sir. Things.

00:10:22

If you look at the current curriculum,

00:10:24

we recently, about 3 - 4 years back we changed,

00:10:28

where we see that, only 15 percent is basic sciences,

00:10:33

15 percent is basic engineering,

00:10:36

then about 45 percent is your departmental,

00:10:39

professional courses,

00:10:40

which includes your projects,

00:10:42

which includes electives and core everything,

00:10:44

and then, about 18 percent free electives now. Okay,

00:10:49

so, the students have a freedom to choose

00:10:51

anything from other departments;

00:10:53

that's more nowadays.

00:10:54

So, because they want to give the

00:10:57

freedom to students to see that. But,

00:10:59

I have a strong opinion

00:11:01

that, without good physics,

00:11:03

without good chemistry,

00:11:04

without good mathematics,

00:11:06

you cannot do good engineering. Correct.

00:11:08

True, you are right, you are right. You will be a messed up in

00:11:10

engineering. I completely agree with you, sir.

00:11:11

You want to do good engineering,

00:11:13

your Pphysics has to be sound,

00:11:16

your chemistry has to be good, Correct.

00:11:18

and, your maths, reasonably

00:11:19

at least, Fortran analysis, you should be able to handle.

00:11:22

True, true. If you can't do that,

00:11:24

Now there is no Fortran you will not be a good engineer.

00:11:26

anymore. Whatever you try.,

00:11:28

you can become a village blacksmith,

00:11:30

but, not a good engineer. True, true, true.

00:11:33

What about your Metallurgy department faculty? Yes,

00:11:35

this is the faculty. Over all faculty.

00:11:37

Professor E. G. Ramachandran is the senior most man.

00:11:41

Very early he got his PhD from Sheffield.

00:11:45

And, they all have... I

00:11:46

heard that he had a record of having

00:11:48

a PhD, when he was 22 years old. 22.

00:11:51

That's amazing. They could have gone to any

00:11:53

place in the world and settled down,

00:11:56

they all came here,

00:11:58

and worked here. And we are all fortunate.

00:12:00

Really, yeah. That's the wonderful thing.

00:12:02

He also worked with a Nobel laureate

00:12:04

Sir C. V. Raman, I think, for 2 years.

00:12:07

And, he is a very,

00:12:09

what the best unique thing about E. G. is that,

00:12:13

its not about engineering and all that,

00:12:15

he wired our brain for more good thinking,

00:12:20

lofty thinking, higher things, Skinner's.

00:12:24

All his classes used to be fantastic;

00:12:27

he took us to a different level, but with one zone;

00:12:30

not mundane, foundry, ramming the sand,

00:12:33

and all that. It is very important

00:12:35

that the students' brain is wired for lofty thinking.

00:12:39

And, that's what he achieved, not the details.

00:12:42

Yeah, I heard that when he teaches physics of materials, Details is not important.

00:12:46

Yes. I... It's amazing, people say.

00:12:48

I only feel that it is not been recorded. Every day,

00:12:50

end of it, it will be like a detective story.

00:12:53

In fact, the NPTEL lectures that we have now,

00:12:56

if they were there those days,

00:12:57

I mean, the students would really... I tried to record,

00:13:00

I called them, but such facilities

00:13:03

Correct. were not there.

00:13:04

Now, now. The day will end

00:13:06

like a detective story. He will say,

00:13:08

"tomorrow we will see how Skinner solve the problem."

00:13:12

You know, So, you will wait for the next day.

00:13:14

whole of Schrodinger's equation,

00:13:18

still is etched in my mind. Wow!

00:13:20

wow, wow. He got up only once.

00:13:22

To take the wave equation and

00:13:23

put down the potential function.

00:13:25

He just said, "this is Schrodinger."

00:13:28

Amazing. Still it is there in my mind. I am a foundry man,

00:13:30

I know. I have nothing to do with physics,

00:13:32

but it is etched in the mind, So, good.

00:13:34

you know, etched in the mind. Good teachers are like that.

00:13:36

So, other than Professor E. G. R., who were the others, sir? He

00:13:39

started industrial metallurgy, very unique thing,

00:13:42

because Chennai is having lot of auto industries,

00:13:46

and that time, auto parts.

00:13:48

So, he formulated industrial metallurgy,

00:13:52

putting, not going into too much theoretical metallurgy,

00:13:55

and all that, in NDT, heat treatment and all that,

00:13:58

it was a great success.

00:13:59

Just to ask there sir... Vasudevan.

00:14:01

you knowm now, recently our department

00:14:05

has started a new programme,

00:14:07

an MTech in industrial metallurgy through e-learning mode.

00:14:10

So, that anyone who is in industry,

00:14:12

who has some BTech or a MSc background

00:14:14

can sit in their industry,

00:14:16

and listen to lectures which

00:14:18

our faculty give in the evening hours,

00:14:20

Excellent idea. 4 to 7,

00:14:21

so that, they don't need to come out of their industry,

00:14:23

and get an MTech degree.

00:14:24

Excellent idea. So, they just come here only for the

00:14:26

convocation, nothing else. See,

00:14:27

So, all the 10 courses, You see,

00:14:29

they sit there and learn.

00:14:30

last 13 years, I have been doing consultancy. Yeah.

00:14:33

I take classes, half of the classes I teach in Tamil,

00:14:37

because the local students don't follow. Ok. Yeah, yeah. I understand, I understand.

00:14:39

But, I tell you, there is an enormous desire

00:14:42

for them to understand the metallurgy True, true.

00:14:44

of the processes they are doing,

00:14:46

they want to know that. Good.

00:14:48

And, IIT faculty and students are in a very unique

00:14:52

and I would say very very fortunate position,

00:14:56

you are all exposed to the very latest.

00:14:58

True sir.

00:14:59

You really don't understand how I know, I know.

00:15:01

fortunate you are; only when you go out,

00:15:03

True, true. I mean going there,

00:15:05

and they want to learn thing.

00:15:07

Particularly with the recent facilities, sir, Yes.

00:15:09

you will be amazed. Yes

00:15:10

Whenever somebody comes from overseas,

00:15:12

they say, "wow, what kind of facilities that you have."

00:15:14

For example, our Metallurgy department right now, has

00:15:17

a Titan, the highest end electronamicroscope with 1 angstrom,

00:15:21

in fact, its 0.6 angstrom resolution;

00:15:24

and, we have got another machine which

00:15:27

is an atom probe, local electrode atom probe,

00:15:29

with about 32 crores we bought it,

00:15:31

which is again first of its kind because,

00:15:33

I know, you are doing very good work, yeah. it can be remotely operated. So, the

00:15:36

whole world, I mean, it's very rare to see a

00:15:38

titan and a leap in the same building in the world,

00:15:42

very few institutions have this.

00:15:44

It's a very, very fortunate You don't even have it

00:15:46

in chemistry. position that people are here in.

00:15:48

Good sir, you were talking about Professor Vasudevan.

00:15:50

Professor Vasudevan, he was a very friendly person.

00:15:56

Within very few minutes, he will give you the feeling

00:15:59

that he, of his scholarship, of his gentlemanliness.

00:16:05

Very sound, his lecture. He got

00:16:08

first teacher award for more than

00:16:11

8 or 10 times in the... Wow, wow.

00:16:13

In IIT, it is tough. I got, maximum I got was 8th rank,

00:16:17

Hhe got first some 6 or 7 times, he got.

00:16:20

Okay. And, the best thing is,

00:16:23

But, you were also known to be an excellent teacher, sir;

00:16:25

many students tell me.

00:16:28

But they were giants.

00:16:31

Ahead of me, there were giants, literally giants. Okay.

00:16:34

Okay, okay. Right. When compared to them, I think, I dwarf myself.

00:16:39

Sreenivasa Raghavan, a man of very high integrity, a no nonsense man.

00:16:45

When I was the head of the department,

00:16:47

I will definitely, I will take his help,

00:16:50

whenever moral, ethical, integrity issues are involved,

00:16:54

I will send him, "sir, it is your field."

00:16:57

Whenever there is something wrong done,

00:16:59

he will make sure that things are done properly and correctly.

00:17:06

He set very high ethical standards,

00:17:09

out of the way, because, you know, outside it is,

00:17:11

the whole thing is rubbish.

00:17:13

But, here, he is setting about very high ethical standards.

00:17:17

Surrealistic. Absolutely surrealistic

00:17:20

and he will set impossible standards.

00:17:23

Anyway, that is K. S. R. for you.

00:17:25

But, very fine gentlemen.

00:17:27

They all added a touch of class to the department.

00:17:31

If they were not there, I would not have joined.

00:17:35

I would not have joined.

00:17:36

They all gave you a feeling

00:17:38

that this is the sophisticated department,

00:17:40

it is a high class department.

00:17:42

I am not going to do anything wrong in being here.

00:17:45

right that is. But, those days, I think,

00:17:47

typically after BTech, people must be joining

00:17:50

some industry and things like that,

00:17:52

what has made you come and do PhD? I went for

00:17:54

post graduation. So, you went for a post graduation outside?

00:17:57

Institute of Science. I did mechanical engineering. Institute of Science.

00:18:00

Okay. Mechanical in the foundry? Then, I went and worked a couple....

00:18:04

Wonderful place, sir, I mean.

00:18:06

I then, went and worked a couple of months

00:18:09

in Coimbatore in foundry.

00:18:12

Okay. And, that was an Alfresco toilet,

00:18:15

so, I just couldn't stay there.

00:18:18

So, came back, E. G. said, "join up."

00:18:21

I had admission in University of Michigan,

00:18:24

to go. In the meantime, Professor E. G. said,

00:18:28

"you may like to stay back."

00:18:30

Kind of indirectly. Didn't tell me...no, not that way,

00:18:34

indirectly encouraged, "you may like to stay here."

00:18:38

I continued, they sent me to DAAD scholarship

00:18:41

and all that, I continued.

00:18:42

So, you joined as a faculty and then did your PhD.

00:18:45

Yes, in those days, at, believe me,

00:18:48

After master's, I think. At 24, I became a lecturer.

00:18:51

Wow. 24. It's impossible now.

00:18:53

With an MTech.

00:18:54

With an M. Tech. Not even a PhD.

00:18:56

Because not many. Now, PhD is a must.

00:18:57

Not only a PhD, PhD with 3 years Postdoc is a must,

00:19:02

according to the new MHRD rules. The things were lenient, they were

00:19:04

lenient that time and continued.

00:19:08

Only, I was doing foundry. Foundry.

00:19:10

It is Professor E. G. who fixed up

00:19:13

one Professor Eberhard Mundry in Germany.

00:19:16

And, he said, "you go and get trained with him

00:19:18

in non destructive testing, it will be very useful for us," and I went.

00:19:22

That's how you have interacted with many... And, Eberhard Mundry was

00:19:24

extraordinarily sincere and good man.

00:19:27

I was fortunate to have good teachers.

00:19:29

Okay. And, he trained he took it upon

00:19:31

himself, as a personal responsibility, to train me up,

00:19:35

I don't regret it.

00:19:36

I make a decent money. Yeah, I heard,

00:19:38

everybody tells that you have started NDT

00:19:40

Yes, yes. in our department.

00:19:43

Not only that,

00:19:44

I have also started American Society of

00:19:47

NDT Examinations - level 1 and level 2 and level 3... Okay, okay.

00:19:51

to help those BScs and MScs,

00:19:55

ordinary BEs, who could not get a good career,

00:19:58

they could do this and even go abroad

00:20:00

this thing, and earn very good lot of money.

00:20:03

Certification done...American certification done in India,

00:20:07

I was one of the first person to start it.

00:20:09

And 100s of them are

00:20:12

now employed throughout Middle East,

00:20:14

Ok. Singapore, Malaysia and all that;

00:20:18

that is one good thing, I suppose, I participated in.

00:20:21

So, when was your date of joining, sir, do you remember?

00:20:24

1968, March.

00:20:26

Here as a faculty?

00:20:27

3rd March or so. And... 3rd March.

00:20:30

3rd March is a very important day, sir,

00:20:31

3rd March is when IISC started.

00:20:34

Okay! J. R. D. Tata's birthday,

00:20:36

here we celebrate. August they promoted me

00:20:39

as lecturer. Both of us have that connection,

00:20:41

I was also a student of IISC.

00:20:43

But those days, for faculty, were there

00:20:45

any advertisements like the current days?

00:20:47

It will come. So, they they were all selected through advertisements?

00:20:51

Professor can... They used to advertise for a specific areas

00:20:55

or not like that, generally? No, metallurgy, that's what I saw,

00:20:58

but I was admitted temporarily as an associate professor first.

00:21:04

And then, they have, thing was regularized

00:21:06

in the lecturer advertisement. So, what were the

00:21:08

hierarchy those days? Associate lecturer,

00:21:11

and then lecturer, Lecturer.

00:21:13

assistant professor, associate and...

00:21:14

So, there was associate professor also, those days?

00:21:16

Yeah. No. Except for some period, there was assistant professor

00:21:19

there. And there was one And, directly professor.

00:21:22

unique category of senior professors.

00:21:24

Only Professor E. G. Ramachandran occupied that post,

00:21:27

nobody else. Okay, now, they call it as a HAG possibly,

00:21:29

something of that nature, okay.

00:21:33

And then, there was Thambiran Ramachandran,

00:21:38

and he later became the principal of Surathkal.

00:21:43

Okay. Beautifully taught you the latest,

00:21:46

very latest that time, dislocations, ternary diagrams.

00:21:49

And, he is also a man of very high integrity.

00:21:52

Uncomfortably, very man of high integrity,.

00:21:55

He taught us things way ahead of other colleges.

00:21:58

Even way ahead of Germany.

00:22:00

I went there. Wow.

00:22:01

Even they didn't have dislocation courses. Wow.

00:22:04

And, he taught us. And, there was one Muthiah,

00:22:07

geology teacher. I specially mention him because,

00:22:12

very boring subject. Exceedingly boring subject, Yeah.

00:22:16

all minerals and... Correct.

00:22:18

But, he used to make it very interesting,

00:22:20

in a very jovial way. Correct.

00:22:22

He was in Civil Engineering department.

00:22:25

Very affectionate, uncomfortably affectionate one.

00:22:30

There was one Dasgupta.

00:22:32

He was a very young man, but bald;

00:22:35

for him the baldness suited very well.

00:22:38

He taught us mechanical metallurgy.

00:22:42

And, he had a unique way of teaching,

00:22:44

he will close his eyes during teaching. Oh.

00:22:46

Even if you want to get out, you can get out.

00:22:51

And, he was quite a, quite a person.

00:22:55

And we have of course,

00:22:57

as a colleague K. A. Padmanabhan came in.

00:23:00

He was...came in like a,

00:23:03

what shall I say, the...

00:23:06

I should have told,

00:23:07

he came in like I wouldn't say china and a bull shop,

00:23:11

but he brought in a lot of expertise.

00:23:14

He opened our eyes to what we can do,

00:23:19

as young teachers and researchers,

00:23:21

he really opened it out.

00:23:23

I think, his coming

00:23:27

showed many of us what can be achieved,

00:23:30

you know, sitting here. True.

00:23:32

And, he showed new horizons. He was very well known for research,

00:23:35

he was very well known for research, I think. Yeah.

00:23:37

Not only that, he literally, see, he

00:23:40

he demoed what is possible.

00:23:42

Wonderful. He was a good addition.

00:23:44

Though, some of his expressions

00:23:46

can be quite uncomfortable.

00:23:48

I said, Churchillian humour with roughage,

00:23:51

but if you ignore it,

00:23:54

he was a tremendous addition to the department. Till then, Yes sir.

00:23:58

That is the. it was slumbering, floundering.

00:24:00

Okay. And then, he just kicked everybody in the rear,

00:24:04

and said, "get going!"

00:24:06

Wonderful. He shook everybody, you know.

00:24:09

And then, just one or two more. Sure, sure, sir.

00:24:13

I out of thing, I appreciate Aravavamudhan,

00:24:16

he took my inorganic chemistry classes.

00:24:20

And, whenever we solve the problem...

00:24:23

supposing, I solve it in a different way,

00:24:26

some radiation, I don't remember,

00:24:29

and he will appreciate it,

00:24:32

he will say, you know, "look at the creativity of this fellow."

00:24:36

And, he will tell in the open class,

00:24:38

"see, you all have done this way, this guy have done this way."

00:24:41

Quiet man, exceedingly quiet man,

00:24:44

but he had that academic deepness.

00:24:49

Fair enough. I appreciated it.

00:24:52

Veluswami, he took our dynamics classes.

00:24:55

Very affectionate guy, person, I shouldn't say guy.

00:25:00

He was our warden also for some time,

00:25:02

he took dynamics classes

00:25:04

and he was also a very friendly person.

00:25:07

Professor Ramanujam, I cannot forget mentioning his name.

00:25:11

There are two Ramanujams,

00:25:12

I am talking about the ore dressing man,

00:25:15

senior man, who is no more now.

00:25:17

And, the best thing is, he showed how physics,

00:25:22

how equations, for example, Stokes law,

00:25:27

they can be very well combined with engineering.

00:25:30

It used to be absolute enlightenment,

00:25:32

how engineering can be done with good physics,

00:25:36

and good mathematics, good understanding.

00:25:38

I think, it's a good example for all.

00:25:40

Mot much relevance to my metallurgy, not much,

00:25:44

but, I used to enjoy his classes

00:25:46

because he used to tie up physics

00:25:48

so, beautifully...it will dance,

00:25:52

physics will dance in his class.

00:25:54

And, at the end of it, you will appreciate the engineering idea.

00:25:57

Wonderful, wonderful. Right, that should be the way.

00:26:00

Wonderful. I really admired him.

00:26:03

S. K. Srinivasan took our maths classes.

00:26:07

A very low tone voice,

00:26:10

but, if you listen carefully, you will be benefited.

00:26:13

I distinctly remember C. R. Muthukrishnan asking him,

00:26:16

"sir, Fourier analysis assumes,

00:26:20

it's only a periodic function from

00:26:21

minus infinity to plus infinity,

00:26:23

then how can you apply it to a impulse pulse?

00:26:27

The explanation, transformation he showed

00:26:29

in the integration is still, it is there in my mind.

00:26:32

A brilliant student with a brilliant teacher,

00:26:35

the effect is IIT.

00:26:39

S. K. Srinivasan, later he took some classes on number theory,

00:26:44

evening classes, I especially went and attended it.

00:26:48

This gentleman is the one who introduced

00:26:51

me to NDT, Professor Eberhard Mundry.

00:26:55

And, he came here for 6 weeks,

00:26:57

we conducted NDT classes and all that, it was full.

00:27:01

At the end of it, he commented,

00:27:03

"all the German professors are having it light,

00:27:05

visiting professors, but you made me work," he said.

00:27:10

He introduced NDT as an academic course,

00:27:13

academic programme in IIT

00:27:16

and you know, how it has taken off,

00:27:18

many of the CDs I have made are based on his...

00:27:20

Their English was not very difficult for you to follow, sir?

00:27:24

Or, you learnt German from him? I know German,

00:27:27

bit, enough for koffeeklatch, I can't boast much,

00:27:30

I attended his classes in Germany. But, they their classes

00:27:32

were all in English?

00:27:34

He is quite good in English,

00:27:35

and whenever he has problem in the class, he will ask me

00:27:39

for the thing. That time, you must realize, how Germany was

00:27:45

in 1971, '72, '73, it was a beaten country

00:27:50

and they were very friendly,

00:27:52

they wanted to be appreciated by the whole world. Okay, okay, okay.

00:27:55

And, they were taking the extraordinary step

00:27:58

to be nice to us, to teach us.

00:28:00

He took it really as his responsibility

00:28:03

Wonderful, wonderful. to put the thing together,

00:28:05

we made very good notes.

00:28:07

Right. Professor Koch was our German professor.

00:28:11

He came to the first class, I remember,

00:28:14

he said 'zat plane,' okay.

00:28:16

Germans, they are talking about jet plane,

00:28:19

we all wrote down 'jet planes.'

00:28:21

Then finally, we found 'that plane' he was pronouncing 'zat plane.'

00:28:28

He, no derivations, concepts.

00:28:33

He will make a wheel rotate and jump on it to show,

00:28:37

we all used to be afraid, the old man should not get injured.

00:28:41

The precision, gyration he used to explain,

00:28:44

he had lot of demo things brought from Germany.

00:28:47

He used whole focus used to be on concept.

00:28:51

Concept. E. G., they, they are the ones who wire the

00:28:56

brains of the students,

00:28:58

Not the boring teachers. I mean, how to say?

00:29:02

They are the ones who wire your brain for better things

00:29:06

True, true, true. in the career.

00:29:10

Scheer, I can't, but mention him.

00:29:12

He took over drawing classes

00:29:15

and later, he was a turbo machines man.

00:29:18

3 semesters he took drawing for us.

00:29:20

Even today, I can tell you,

00:29:22

I can read a drawing happily without problem due to his training.

00:29:27

He used to insist that my letterings,

00:29:29

number should be at 70 degrees.

00:29:35

Thorough Germanness; if you want to see German genius in action,

00:29:39

he was the one.

00:29:41

He he really taught what

00:29:45

what is the difference between Germans and others.

00:29:47

How beautifully they do things so carefully,

00:29:50

so punctiliously. No class is simple class for him,

00:29:54

no lab class is simple for him; full zeal,

00:29:58

Full energy he will put in, even for a simple

00:30:01

45 minute lecture on bolds, not coming, no.

00:30:07

great sir. Great They all really impressive.

00:30:09

great teachers those days they are. Scheer,

00:30:12

if that doesn't teach you about German thoroughness, nothing will.

00:30:18

Klein, he was a kind of a jolly good person,

00:30:23

he taught us German, he used to come well dressed,

00:30:26

gold rimmed glasses on those days,

00:30:28

quite a handsome guy.

00:30:29

But, he was great very popular with the students.

00:30:33

Ebert associated with the workshop,

00:30:36

he used to be a terror,

00:30:38

we lost some good students

00:30:39

because of the toughness in the thing,

00:30:43

quite a good, I remember, I don't want to name them.

00:30:46

They were very good, Andhra University first and all that,

00:30:49

but just because they have failed in workshop,

00:30:51

they were asked to leave, that was somewhat sad,

00:30:54

because, they would have made an electronics engineer,

00:30:57

everybody need not use hacksaw blade and

00:31:01

we all felt bad when that thing.

00:31:03

But, then, he was strict,

00:31:07

you got to do, you have to chip,

00:31:09

you have to machine, no question, he will walk around.

00:31:14

Professor Anantharaman, you have to mention him.

00:31:17

He took us industrial economics;

00:31:19

full of jokes, students loved him

00:31:23

and all the programmes, your

00:31:28

all culture, he used to be the main figure.

00:31:30

He was a great hit,

00:31:32

and he used to crack jokes in the class

00:31:35

bit on the other side,

00:31:36

but, people used to love it,

00:31:39

people used to love his class.

00:31:42

There was one Dr. D. V. Reddy, he left subsequently.

00:31:45

He took applied mechanics

00:31:48

and he was great hit with the students.

00:31:51

Students will shout, "joke sir, joke sir" and

00:31:53

he will crack a joke; he was good and he left.

00:31:57

There was one Gangadharan, a very diminutive figure.

00:32:01

I mentioned him because, he took applied mechanics.

00:32:05

Again, a brilliant teacher,

00:32:07

I still remember his Taylor series expansion,

00:32:10

McClaren series expansion, right;

00:32:13

uniquely excellent teacher.

00:32:16

Later, he went to Thailand

00:32:18

and I heard that he settled down there.

00:32:22

Dr. Swaminathan, he was my great friend.

00:32:26

Physics teacher he came with the bow

00:32:29

bow tie and black coat to the first class,

00:32:32

taught us diffraction, you know him well.

00:32:35

And, diffraction, interference and all that.

00:32:39

Later, subsequently, he became, he left all this thing.

00:32:44

He used to be very friendly to me,

00:32:46

and particularly to me,

00:32:48

and we have spent many evenings in Bangalore together.

00:32:51

He was a bachelor till he died.

00:32:54

And, a fantastic fellow to know, unlike any professor.

00:33:01

There was one Professor Varma in chemical engineering.

00:33:04

Very methodical person, I used to admire his very

00:33:11

beautiful way to present things, very systematic

00:33:15

and I also liked him, chemical engineering.

00:33:17

There was one Seshadri who left, he was in chemical.

00:33:20

Very flamboyant figure, he will come to our hostel

00:33:23

and demonstrate Colorado movie and all that.

00:33:28

There was one Professor K. I. Vasu in metallurgy.

00:33:31

He was also in IISC, no, sir? IISC later.

00:33:34

He became director of CECRI.

00:33:36

Affection incarnate right, he is such a friendly guy. Yeah,

00:33:41

he left by the time I joined.

00:33:42

Yes. He will, if I have a problem, So, I have not...

00:33:45

he will make sure that he can,

00:33:48

he will extend some help to the extent he can.

00:33:52

Very nice person.

00:33:54

Among the directors, I admire this man, A. Ramachandran. Why?

00:33:59

The reason is, he set the tone for research in IIT.

00:34:03

Before that, it was purely an undergraduate institute,

00:34:06

he set this direction for IIT to go towards the research.

00:34:09

And. I think, I think, all that beginning is what

00:34:12

now paying us, we got, last 2 years, a number 1 rank

00:34:16

which is majority basically for... He used to encourage

00:34:18

young people. He will walk around research.

00:34:20

and whenever a young person is working,

00:34:22

he will go near him and encourage him.

00:34:24

"Is there any problem for you

00:34:26

to get stores?" He will go and ask.

00:34:28

Very good, wonderful, wonderful. Right.

00:34:31

Very rare person. Because of his personality,

00:34:34

academic personality, many people have left their jobs

00:34:39

from abroad and joined here.

00:34:41

Sheer personality, force of personality, I mean.

00:34:45

I used to admire him, he doesn't know me much.

00:34:48

I know. When I mention these people, as a student, I admired.

00:34:52

True, true. Do they know me? I was a small fellow.

00:34:56

True, true. After all the BTech, you know,

00:35:01

what made you choose teaching as a profession?

00:35:04

Are there any people or some Well,

00:35:06

my experience in. that you want to share with us?

00:35:09

foundry was not a good one on the health front.

00:35:13

As I said, professionally, I was happy.

00:35:16

There was one Belgian expert,

00:35:19

he was designing the things and he didn't know mathematics,

00:35:22

he didn't know how to use slide rule,

00:35:24

and so, I was helping him.

00:35:26

So, it was a good interaction.

00:35:28

I was doing the gating design and all that;

00:35:30

every night we used to sit and calculate.

00:35:32

I was learning a lot,

00:35:34

but, as I said, it was in Karamadai. Okay.

00:35:36

And, it was Alfresco toilet, there was no decent toilet.

00:35:40

Oh. You know animals will be around.

00:35:43

So, I told them, "I need a decent toilet,"

00:35:48

they said, "we give only to foreigners, not to Indians." Oh.

00:35:52

Then, I said, "okay," and came back

00:35:54

and asked Professor E. G. R., E. G. R., E. G. R.

00:35:57

Okay. "can I join?" He said, "you're most welcome."

00:36:00

Professor M. R. Seshadri. It's a boon,

00:36:02

boon to our in in department, I think.

00:36:05

Indians Any a discomfort for you

00:36:07

in Coimbatore became a boon to IIT Madras. Professor

00:36:10

M. R. Seshadri of Indian Institute of Science,

00:36:13

whom again, I admire a lot. He taught me,

00:36:15

ferrous metallurgy, ferrous foundry. He called me,

00:36:18

and said, "if you are going to join as a teacher

00:36:21

why don't you come here?

00:36:22

We have a foundry section,

00:36:24

and I know, you can do a decent job of teaching.

00:36:27

Why don't you come and join us?"

00:36:29

But my family situation is around Chennai.

00:36:32

So, I told him, "I would rather be here."

00:36:34

And, that is how, one toilet changed my career.

00:36:40

You wanted to talk about your friends? But,

00:36:42

I liked my stay in the industry. Good.

00:36:46

It was steel industry.

00:36:47

And, you know, metallurgy is And, you are still

00:36:49

full of metallurgy. connected with the industry, yeah, I am aware of that.

00:36:51

Every day, I used to go home only at 11 o' clock in the night,

00:36:55

see the last pouring

00:36:57

You are a rare academician, see it is defect free and then go home.

00:36:59

who is always connected with the industry. I love this.

00:37:02

I love to do. Friends, C. R. M.

00:37:06

He was our deputy director here,

00:37:08

he was a star in our department, you know?

00:37:11

He was a teacher for all of us,

00:37:13

I am very shamelessly telling you.

00:37:15

Right, if I have any doubt,

00:37:18

we won't even go into his room,

00:37:20

there is a window, we will all sit there,

00:37:22

from inside he will say charge is there,

00:37:24

this calculate that...Very generous fellow,

00:37:28

We all admired him for his scholarship

00:37:31

and brilliant mind. I have seen,

00:37:35

when all of us are struggling to get pass mark,

00:37:38

he will come out with a distinction

00:37:41

or near 100 percent, right?

00:37:43

When you are beaten in a straight competition,

00:37:46

it is very easy to admire a man.

00:37:50

There is no second thoughts on his brilliance.

00:37:54

Kripanarayan, he was in civil engineering first,

00:37:57

he is in a big time fellow now.

00:37:59

He designs all seismic...his only complaint is,

00:38:03

that lot of IITians in US

00:38:06

are doing very well in other fields other than IT and teaching;

00:38:10

"why you are not giving Distinguished Alumnus Award,

00:38:14

even though they are applying?"

00:38:15

The one complaint he had when I met him last time in California,

00:38:19

and I am just telling, just a thought.

00:38:22

He feel there are some...only there you are looking

00:38:24

at IT or teaching profession,

00:38:26

you are not looking at any other.

00:38:28

He has developed earthquake free buildings,

00:38:33

and they are all, their software's are very popular.

00:38:36

He says, people are not looking at those contributions.

00:38:40

And, I said, "did you apply?"

00:38:43

He said, "yes, we do apply,

00:38:44

but we are simply pushed aside."

00:38:48

Mahesh, he is a close friend of mine,

00:38:51

he belongs to the TVS family.

00:38:53

His Go-Kart was very uniquely popular on the campus,

00:38:57

he designed a Go-Kart by himself.

00:38:59

And, we used to go, I used to go on his Go-Kart,

00:39:01

he is a close friend of mine.

00:39:03

We also made a semi

00:39:06

semi-working a blast furnace for the department, in those days.

00:39:10

And, it was there for a long time, till they threw it out.

00:39:14

He is an engineering genius.

00:39:16

Three process control - pressure diecasting,

00:39:20

brake lining, gravity diecasting he has introduced,

00:39:23

and all of them are working exceptionally well. Alright.

00:39:28

K. Narayanan, also known as Ghost.

00:39:32

He is the binding force for 1965 batch.

00:39:38

I can't think of 1965 batch without Ghost, alright.

00:39:44

And, he is keeping all, the whole flock together.

00:39:48

Even now, we get in...

00:39:49

"oh, Amitabha died," I get information immediately,

00:39:52

Patnaik died, I will get the information.

00:39:56

Is he the same person...chemical engineering?

00:39:59

Yeah, yeah, very good, okay.

00:40:01

He is a very nice fellow,

00:40:03

no caste feeling, no religious,

00:40:06

no, no silly things, he will hug everybody; a beautiful fellow.

00:40:14

He is my friend J. Vivekanandan.

00:40:16

A unique story, we both studied in Ambasamudram

00:40:19

together in school,

00:40:21

and when I joined IIT, he was standing there,

00:40:24

I said "what are you doing here?"

00:40:25

He said, "what are you doing here?"

00:40:28

So, he did his thing, he is right now

00:40:31

fabricating very good systems

00:40:34

for food processing and so on, and brilliant fellow.

00:40:40

Kapoor, I don't know this man personally,

00:40:45

he was my classmate in 1965 batch,

00:40:49

but, I really appreciated him because, he started the film club.

00:40:54

He will go all the way to Mount Road,

00:40:57

bring that 60 mm thing on his bicycle.

00:40:59

He used to sit in the veranda of Building Sciences,

00:41:03

civil engineering and he will yank it up,

00:41:05

it won't work. And, then, we were always seeing the movie,

00:41:09

that's all the entertainment we had,

00:41:11

that is how our movie club started

00:41:14

and... OAT was there those days?

00:41:15

No. It started only in '64. No OAT. Okay.

00:41:18

Okay. And, it used to be the only entertainment for us.

00:41:22

I know, I know. Games or wait for Saturday evening Kapoor's movie.

00:41:27

Okay. He will bring some movie.

00:41:30

Good. Yeah. We all used to look forward to it.

00:41:32

So, you so, that tradition is still continuing. What.

00:41:34

Even now, it is Saturday evening movie for us.

00:41:37

See, what an enterprise,

00:41:39

for a young man.

00:41:40

When we were all struggling for my cycle,

00:41:43

for my education thing,

00:41:44

this guy goes on a bike, brings the movie,

00:41:47

shows it to all of for nothing,

00:41:49

not even an applause,

00:41:53

right? That, I call it the spirit of doing things.

00:41:57

That's true. Right? That is about IIT.

00:41:59

You cannot, but admire him.

00:42:01

I don't know the man,

00:42:03

probably, he also doesn't know.

00:42:05

That is about the thing.

00:42:07

Good good sir. Sorry, I am talking too much.

00:42:09

No, no sir its. Lot of interesting things. These topics are too close to me.

00:42:13

What were the major facilities, those days,

00:42:15

you know, in the department?

00:42:16

Not much, not much. When you look at it,

00:42:18

not much. Not much.

00:42:19

And, the projects, do you have a lot of industry projects?

00:42:24

Industry used to put in money?

00:42:26

When I was a student, there was practically no facility.

00:42:29

But, when I came as a faculty, there was quite a few Okay.

00:42:33

facilities were available,

00:42:35

but, not research category.

00:42:37

Okay, you left in '98, you know, sir or?

00:42:40

'98 I left. Yeah.

00:42:42

July 29th, my birthday, I left. '98, 29th.

00:42:45

Okay, okay. 60 years.

00:42:46

60 years, okay. So, so, those days,

00:42:50

basically, the major facility, electron microscope...

00:42:53

these things were there, those days?

00:42:55

Were there. Were there.

00:42:56

SCM was not there. SCM...

00:42:58

Professor Gokulrathnam, we used to hear a lot about him.

00:43:01

And then we had facilities.

00:43:04

Okay. The problem with a Metallurgy Department is, it was

00:43:09

too much fragmented. Yeah, even now,

00:43:11

So. That didn't...that we are in five different buildings.

00:43:13

didn't help us to have a synergy.

00:43:15

Correct, correct. We are trying to move into a new building, sir. So...

00:43:18

that, you told me that. That would be of great help. Very soon, very soon.

00:43:21

That's true. The synergy, that you meet your colleague...

00:43:24

like, when I worked in Singapore,

00:43:26

some quantum mechanics guy will ask me,

00:43:30

"can you melt this alloy?"

00:43:32

That synergy was absent to work together.

00:43:35

Lot of sponsored projects used to be there, those days?

00:43:38

DST? Where, which were the sponsoring agencies those days?

00:43:41

DST used to give DST used to give.

00:43:44

a major portion. Major portion.

00:43:46

UGC used to give something like grants,

00:43:48

they never used to bother about our report. Now, UGC doesn't give

00:43:51

to IIT because, IIT is under MHRD

00:43:54

it is not under UGC, so.

00:43:56

And Germans used to have a collaborative agreement

00:43:59

for some sort... So, all of you used to

00:44:01

go to Germany often, faculty? No, I went twice.

00:44:05

My problem with Germany is...

00:44:07

See, all my friends who went to US,

00:44:11

have developed very good professional contacts,

00:44:13

excellent professional contacts.

00:44:16

US, you are able to put yourself in an equal position.

00:44:21

In Germany, you are always patronized.

00:44:23

Okay. And, it is very difficult to get, you are always a newcomer,

00:44:29

and, you don't build.

00:44:31

I told this even to some German officials.

00:44:33

I have been there 2 years, totally, together I spent,

00:44:37

but what is the professional contact I have? Nil.

00:44:41

Even now, I am treated as a foreigner.

00:44:43

Whereas, I worked 2 years in US,

00:44:46

I have much better professional contact there.

00:44:48

True, true. Sir.

00:44:49

See...yes? Hello. Mr. Muthuraman Tata,

00:44:56

was he your classmate? No, no,

00:44:57

he was junior. Junior.

00:44:58

I see. He was a good cricketer.

00:45:01

And, even I am...

00:45:06

I recommended his name for Distinguished Alumnus Award,

00:45:09

even before he became all that famous. Correct,

00:45:12

correct. And, he is, you know, the vice president of

00:45:16

TISCO and all that. Yeah, he was a gem.

00:45:18

He is now settled in Bangalore.

00:45:20

He retired from Tata Steel. sir.

00:45:22

Yeah. I recommended.

00:45:24

Correct. In fact,

00:45:24

even Dr. Krishna's Das Nair was the first batch, I think, sir? He is

00:45:27

senior to me. 1 year senior to you, first batch.

00:45:30

I heard. But, we were all in the same hostel.

00:45:32

Oh Yeah. Okay. Nair, me.

00:45:34

Santhanam, Natarajan, all were in the same hostel.

00:45:38

You also had other roles, some administrative roles?

00:45:41

You were a head of the department for some period right? So, I was head for 3, one.

00:45:45

Warden I was there. You were a warden.

00:45:47

I... '87 to '90, I think, you are head of the department?

00:45:50

Any of those days, do you remember,

00:45:53

any major changes? Well, I would...

00:45:55

tried to bring. Okay. brought in a lot, lot of money I brought in.

00:45:58

Okay. Because I had a very good stores officer Chari.

00:46:02

We used to get all the papers ready.

00:46:05

In February, there will be a rush

00:46:09

because, there will be lot of money,

00:46:11

no effective programme to spend it.

00:46:15

Okay. So, the director will be asking in the senate, "do you have any plan?"

00:46:18

We will go and give it and

00:46:20

get. What was the level of funding you used to get

00:46:21

for the department? Can you tell me some number? Very low, very low.

00:46:25

3 lakhs per year for 25 faculty members. 3 lakhs per year.

00:46:28

For 25. So, there were about 25 faculty. 3 lakhs. 25, 27...

00:46:32

3 lakhs. So, just to tell you now,

00:46:34

it's about close to 2 crores.

00:46:36

1.6 to 1.7 crores, is what we get per year.

00:46:41

Then. I mean, that includes what we call it as,

00:46:44

you know, recurring, non recurring put together.

00:46:46

So, that's about one point for our department.

00:46:48

So, significant improvement and we are about 31 faculty now.

00:46:52

Okay. We... So, number of faculty did not increased much.

00:46:55

Never. Many of us But, the amount of funding has significantly.

00:46:57

never used to depend on department money,

00:47:00

Yeah. we used to give it off

00:47:01

True, true. to the head to spend it.

00:47:03

True. And, that money you used We used to depend on.

00:47:05

to distribute to all the faculty? Those 3 lakhs? Yeah, each will get

00:47:08

some 15000 or something.

00:47:09

So, their spare parts and all they can buy. Now, each

00:47:12

faculty gets almost close to about 1.5 lakhs.

00:47:15

Oh, that's a decent money. 1.5, that's the department...

00:47:17

in addition, of course, people have their own projects,

00:47:20

many of them. But, the end of the audit year money,

00:47:25

I got close to 2 crores to the department. Okay.

00:47:28

In fact, Professor Srinath told me,

00:47:30

"you are walking in with papers and

00:47:32

going away with money, what's happening?"

00:47:34

We were perfect. I knew the system.

00:47:37

We were perfectly ready with the papers,

00:47:39

quotations, everything; Chari was an excellent stores officer.

00:47:44

Right. We got, put the paper, get the funding,

00:47:47

because, nobody was ready.

00:47:49

What...all good equipment, we got SCM like that.

00:47:52

Yeah, yeah good. Good, good. All good equipment we got.

00:47:54

We got, we got that instronic,

00:47:56

instron machine we got it under that.

00:47:59

I myself bought a computer system for myself,

00:48:03

DOS based, 2 and half lakhs at that time, I bought it.

00:48:08

Any important experiences as a faculty you want to share?

00:48:12

Important experience. It was a good run. During your period?

00:48:16

The students were simply brilliant.

00:48:20

I have taught in Singapore for nearly 8 years,

00:48:23

no comparison. How were the PhD students?

00:48:26

You used to have a lot of PhD students, those days?

00:48:29

Good students. I mean, they were given scholarships and....

00:48:32

I think, all of them are now in US. So, so they...

00:48:34

Chinnathambi is in US.

00:48:36

Madhusudhana is in US.

00:48:38

Venkataraman is working in air force base in Hampton.

00:48:46

All have done very well.

00:48:47

Krishna Kumar is the present head of CAD centre,

00:48:51

he was my PhD scholar.

00:48:53

All have done exceptionally well.

00:48:54

Prasanna Kumar became a professor here,

00:48:57

T. S. Prasanna Kumar. Then later, he went, Yeah, yeah, he retired recently.

00:49:00

he became the head of the department. Institute of Science, he was also my student.

00:49:03

He was also with Tata Steel for sometime, I think,

00:49:06

what are the. Yeah he, He was brilliant, no doubt about that.

00:49:08

I mean, see one German professor told me, is brilliant.

00:49:12

"there are brilliant people all around India;

00:49:14

we have no doubt about it,

00:49:16

but when we take an IIT student,

00:49:19

we are assured of the quality, nothing more."

00:49:22

"See, I get from all backgrounds, Yeah.

00:49:24

but, we have to select. Yeah true.

00:49:26

He is good, though I select."

00:49:27

"There are brilliant people everywhere, True.

00:49:29

but," he said, "when you take an IIT student,

00:49:31

the average is assured to me."

00:49:33

That's all he said,

00:49:34

"the average competence is assured."

00:49:38

What are the major changes do you see over the years?

00:49:41

You left the institute '98,

00:49:43

its close to about 20 years now.

00:49:46

So, when you come to the institute and department

00:49:49

do you see things are changing for good? Yes.

00:49:52

Yes, I feel that the orientation is going from

00:49:57

the conventional industrial metallurgy, that is the thing because,

00:50:01

all the young people want to be in the main flow of research

00:50:06

that is taking place in the world,

00:50:08

they want to be in nanomaterials, tuff ceramics and all that.

00:50:11

In addition, we are doing a lot of work on steel, sir, for example,

00:50:14

just for your information, recently ministry of steel gave

00:50:17

I saw that, I saw that. 35 crores to us,

00:50:20

Centre of Excellence in Steel tTechnology. That's a very good development.

00:50:22

Particularly, as you rightly said, because auto industry is here.

00:50:26

So, this is A very good development.

00:50:27

a very good development.

00:50:28

Very good development, excellent development. Okay.

00:50:30

Ultimately, our country needs very good

00:50:37

old fashioned metallurgists. I go around,

00:50:40

True, true. we don't get many.

00:50:42

Many, all kind of charlatans and fakes are there, right.

00:50:47

We don't have a good seasoned metallurgist, we don't find.

00:50:54

There are few, they are all my own students or friends,

00:50:58

they are all there, not many, less than 5.

00:51:01

Any other memories you want to share with us?

00:51:04

Let me see whether I have any, my memory is not good.

00:51:08

Right and...IT, AI and robotics, 00:51:4,140 --> 00:51:15,720 everywhere they are introducing.

00:51:15

A time was there, when we were going towards computer department.

00:51:19

Now, they are coming to us.

00:51:21

True. This is the change.

00:51:23

And, all the IT, they are looking for application fields,

00:51:26

they are coming towards us. Earlier we used to go

00:51:29

to Muthukrishnan and all, now they are coming to us.

00:51:32

I think, department may like to think of,

00:51:35

say, artificial intelligence, IT, automation robotics

00:51:39

in NDT, all coming in a big way.

00:51:42

I think, you may like to position yourself. Sure

00:51:45

sir, sure sir. So, that our students also feel

00:51:46

True, true. good,

00:51:48

not conventional metallurgy. Sir, just to tell you, sir,

00:51:50

for quite some time, till now, I would say, till the last year,

00:51:55

we have what is called dual degree programme.

00:51:58

For example, if somebody joins in metallurgy, he goes

00:52:00

out with a BTech in metallurgical materials

00:52:02

engineering and MTech in metallurgical materials engineering.

00:52:05

We are starting a number of interdisciplinary MTech programmes. Excellent,

00:52:08

excellent. Okay, where somebody joins in metallurgy, let's say,

00:52:11

goes out with robotics as MTech. Excellent.

00:52:13

It is needed. He has BTech metallurgy, MTech robotics.

00:52:16

So, similarly, automation, data mining, okay,

00:52:20

I mean, big data is one and AI.

00:52:23

So, these are all the areas where we are starting. Correct, true. See, they are coming to us.

00:52:28

Its good time for us to position ourselves. True,

00:52:30

true. See, earlier, I had to go then, FORTRON

00:52:33

/400, I have to give the card, I have to be like standing in queue,

00:52:39

now, all those guys are around us.

00:52:41

"Right, do you have any good project to do?" That's true, sir, that's...sure.

00:52:45

Let us do. That Sure, sure.

00:52:47

puts in some sophistication to our field.

00:52:50

Physically fragmented department, I told you.

00:52:53

I think by next That is the main issue.

00:52:55

June we will be in our place. This is, this has...

00:52:57

otherwise Metallurgy department would have gone much farther.

00:53:02

Surprise...this is, just I put.

00:53:04

Peer group, this is a best thing I had in IIT,

00:53:08

the discussions I had in the bathroom,

00:53:12

in front of the bathroom, in the corridor, with my friends

00:53:15

they were the best discussions.

00:53:17

I had one friend Amitav Pattnaik,

00:53:19

he used to explain to me martensitic transformations,

00:53:22

both used to be in our lungis and towel.

00:53:25

Right, and the way he explained it is

00:53:28

far whatever was taught in the class.

00:53:31

Wonderful. True, true. The peer group is what makes the difference in IIT.

00:53:37

What teaches the IIT student -

00:53:40

Aim high, compete internationally,

00:53:43

give way to superior talent;

00:53:45

somebody superior comes, give way,

00:53:48

don't go stop him,

00:53:50

that's one thing we learn.

00:53:51

There are people who are above us. Correct.

00:53:54

So, when a superior guy comes

00:53:55

give a way and applaud him,

00:53:57

that's what I have learnt in IIT.

00:53:58

Because, we are all good,

00:54:00

and, even among the good, there were some better, right? True, true, true.

00:54:03

So, we have to applaud him. True.

00:54:04

There are no other way. True, true.

00:54:06

Do your job well. True.

00:54:08

So, the next man who comes to my job,

00:54:10

should know, he has to exceed that. Okay.

00:54:13

True, we have to set... Comments I receive when I go to industry,

00:54:18

they have they they always tell,

00:54:20

the undergraduates have a problem to work with others.

00:54:23

I received this comment not less than half a dozen of time,

00:54:27

they have some issue. They are willing to work IT,

00:54:31

but you put as a group and ask them to develop a design,

00:54:34

they don't do well, they have

00:54:38

some air and all that.

00:54:40

There are lot of IIT students who are not very good,

00:54:43

they suffer a lot by comparison,

00:54:44

there were guys who do very well in

00:54:47

California, make millions of dollars.

00:54:49

Let's not forget they are equally good number who have not done well. Okay.

00:54:53

And, many of the students are

00:54:57

off late, they are not interested in metallurgy, some students,

00:55:00

they come here just to get a seal, IIT Madras.

00:55:04

True sir. And, we are wasting a lot of money.

00:55:06

True, sir. This is a poor country

00:55:08

and... I will just share one experience of mine.

00:55:10

I used to teach these first year, we used to have

00:55:14

an introduction to metallurgy and materials engineering.

00:55:17

So, one of my goals in that class was, at the end of the class

00:55:20

to ensure that not many change their branch

00:55:23

and then they start liking metallurgy

00:55:25

to an extent. That they don't feel like changing That's a good.

00:55:27

the branch. So, metallurgy is exciting, sir, really. It's a good thing.

00:55:30

Exciting, but... Only thing is, people always

00:55:33

compare them... I can give you lot of instances

00:55:36

where students have made caustic remarks.

00:55:39

They would not like to do anything to do with

00:55:42

metallurgy in their life,

00:55:44

they will just go to business administration, or computers That's true.

00:55:47

"I am just here to get your certificate," they will tell to me. Correct.

00:55:50

Correct. I will give them a seal,

00:55:52

"you are a great guy, IIT product, you know."

00:55:56

Another thing I find is, you have got all bright students, nerdy students,

00:56:02

it may be good to get a Nobel Prize,

00:56:05

but, if in engineering we must go forward,

00:56:08

we should be like Cambridge.

00:56:10

We should admit some high level politicians

00:56:14

from various countries, their children,

00:56:16

some industrialists' children, because the combination will do very good.

00:56:20

I myself can tell from experience.

00:56:23

Supposing, imagine, a very big industrialists' son

00:56:26

is a friend of one very bright student,

00:56:28

they get together for 4 years;

00:56:30

the combination, just like Cambridge, Cambridge does it beautifully.

00:56:34

There are certain admissions they do

00:56:36

for people who are technically or scientifically or politically...

00:56:42

because, only study...he is a nerd.

00:56:44

You put all together, they go out and to life,

00:56:47

he can get a Nobel prize.

00:56:50

But, engineering needs some wealth. Correct.

00:56:52

It's wealth creation is engineering.

00:56:54

So, IIT should think...it is, there is nothing wrong

00:56:58

f a big industrialists' son is admitted

00:57:02

so, that he is put in touch with good bright student,

00:57:06

they become friends and that can be

00:57:09

an explosive growth for India...because this guy has the brain,

00:57:12

this fellow has the influence and money.

00:57:15

We should try to...Cambridge does it.

00:57:17

Cambridge does it, right?

00:57:19

How our all big politicians children go to Cambridge. We have to check.

00:57:23

Combination is good. Yeah. Whereas, here, everything is through JEE.

00:57:26

Through merit, merit, merit. That fellow may not.

00:57:28

Good. You can get a Nobel Prize, That's where the problem.

00:57:30

But engineering is not about that. That

00:57:32

businessman's son may not come to JEE. Finally, we have to create wealth in the society, right?

00:57:36

I understand. This, I am very clear

00:57:38

about it, because personally, I was benefited It's a good idea sir yeah.

00:57:42

by some of my friends who are well up in industry

00:57:45

Later, they used to call me, "why don't you solve the problem?"

00:57:49

It puts you in a very good position,

00:57:51

because, he appreciates you, you are with him as a student,

00:57:54

he has got a very high opinion about you,

00:57:56

he says, "come and do my job."

00:57:59

IIT Madras, very good peer group, I have told you;

00:58:03

staff and students are very fortunate,

00:58:05

unless you go out you will not realize it;

00:58:10

and can we do a cricket in research? This is my question.

00:58:16

If I look at our bright cricketer jumping around,

00:58:21

can we do a similar thing in research?

00:58:23

What...look at Kohli,

00:58:27

Jadeja flying. In my days,

00:58:30

the cricketer cannot even bend to pick up the ball,

00:58:34

they used to be fat, right? I don't want to name.

00:58:38

Pakistan versus India, 1965 I went and saw,

00:58:41

the opening batsman could not bend to pick up the ball.

00:58:45

Now, you can...look at, look at the way they are flying. Yeah, yeah, it's good.

00:58:48

Can we do a similar cricket in research?

00:58:51

I think, reasonably things are happening well, sir.

00:58:55

Well. But the, you know... We are well known...

00:58:57

uniform comment I receive when I go abroad,

00:59:00

from Japanese and all that,

00:59:01

"we are not able to use your data fully,

00:59:05

we are not, it is unreliable data,"

00:59:07

the one comment they make very often.

00:59:10

I say, "we are producing so much of data, why you are not...?"

00:59:13

The comment Japanese professors make very sharply

00:59:16

to me, "we like your ideas,

00:59:18

but we are not able to use your data."

00:59:21

But, we have to take it seriously. Seriously, sir.

00:59:24

So, we have to assure data integrity

00:59:27

when we do it.

00:59:28

There is no question of saying I am good, he is bad, no.

00:59:31

We have to assure it, because, there is a general feeling

00:59:34

and we are spending a lot of manpower, energy.

00:59:37

And, all our equipment have to be third party inspected,

00:59:41

I am very very clear of that. True, true, true.

00:59:43

They have...we have to bring in thing, check our

00:59:47

machines for their calibration,

00:59:49

sensitivity. No, we shouldn't do that,

00:59:51

we should bring...so, for example, Instron

00:59:53

it should be calibrated by outside parties Yeah.

00:59:56

and then, like NASA, where I worked

00:59:59

for 2 years as a contractor.

01:00:01

Then, that data becomes valid

01:00:04

and, lot of value is attached to the data...

01:00:08

two minor things.

01:00:10

Professor Nigam once told me, when I was here,

01:00:13

he was also my maths teacher, he said

01:00:15

"your job is at the table,

01:00:17

don't go around the conferences and jump"

01:00:20

he said; very good advice, at a very young age,

01:00:25

and I was only hardly 24, 25.

01:00:28

Just we were walking,

01:00:30

then I said, "I joined sir," he said, "very good,

01:00:32

remember one thing, your job is at the table,

01:00:35

don't go about attending conference and getting award,

01:00:38

that is not your job," he said,

01:00:41

struck me very well, right.

01:00:43

But, one thing you should appreciate,

01:00:45

I received good advice and tried to follow.

01:00:50

Alumni, I was thing...we did a few things in alumni.

01:00:54

Present, I am now a consultant to few...

01:00:57

I make multimedia educational DVDs. Yeah.

01:01:01

This, you're very famous with. Yes,

01:01:02

I also introduced level 1, level 2, level 3 for NDT - it's a great success.

01:01:08

All animated, all phase diagrams,

01:01:10

I have animated, they are selling very well.

01:01:13

Many DVDs I sell. I also make an equipment

01:01:17

called acoustic analyzer for testing components.

01:01:22

This also sells well and that's about it.

01:01:26

Just sorry, I... Mamata, you want to ask some things?

01:01:28

You didn't mentioned anything about the

01:01:32

Indo-German project with Padmanabhan,

01:01:35

what was it about?

01:01:38

The project was essentially to modernize the laboratory,

01:01:43

and he had one Instron machine.

01:01:46

And, essentially, to upgrade, but they call it as

01:01:51

upgrade the metal forming laboratory facilities.

01:01:55

So, it was not...

01:01:57

then, later, they took up one specific project,

01:02:00

initially, it was upgrading, the upgradation of the laboratory.

01:02:04

Sir, not for, I am sorry, metal testing or anything like that?

01:02:09

It was a metal testing. crepe and all that, the what is it?

01:02:12

Not crepe, metal forming.

01:02:15

I see, mainly metal forming? Metal forming.

01:02:17

Fine, sir, fine. Metal forming they did superplastic materials

01:02:22

and all that, that is his specialty,

01:02:24

super plastic material, they were doing all that.

01:02:28

Professor O. P. There are some photographs of your time,

01:02:33

Yes. we wanted you to just recognize them,

01:02:36

and maybe, you make a few comments about them. Yeah.

01:02:38

That is metal forming unit for extrusion.

01:02:43

another one. And, this is second one,

01:02:45

is in the metal forming lab.

01:02:48

This was set up by Professor P. Venugopal.

01:02:51

Yeah. Famous. And, he is a very well known

01:02:53

expert in metal forming.

01:02:56

Can you recognize the man who is doing the testing sir?

01:02:59

Not much. Not much. Not much. By any chance, no? Okay, okay.

01:03:03

But, the units are all Professor Wagener,

01:03:06

not the vibrations' Wagener, there

01:03:08

was another Wagener. Okay.

01:03:10

He was also a very...he developed the laboratory very sincerely.

01:03:15

Professor Venugopal was closely associated with him. Okay.

01:03:19

They set up all these facility. He is fashion about...

01:03:22

really. Yeah, extrusion and all that facility.

01:03:25

And, this is a unit that is Till there

01:03:28

This is still there. yeah, this also metal forming.

01:03:32

And, these are all old type...

01:03:34

nowadays, people have changed the electronics everything, considerably.

01:03:39

And, this is again, German equipment

01:03:45

for high temperature testing and so on.

01:03:48

Metal forming, deep drawing and so on...

01:03:50

they have so many areas.

01:03:53

And, these two, this is a contact pyrometer

01:03:58

developed by Professor H. Mohammed Roshan.

01:04:01

He was my very esteemed colleague. He...

01:04:04

He is coming next month, here. Yeah,

01:04:05

he comes every year. We both decided on fine morning that we will leave IIT.

01:04:09

He went to US and I went to Singapore.

01:04:12

Yeah, okay. Right and hard worker,

01:04:16

Yeah he is also a... beyond imagination.

01:04:19

see. And, this is again, forging facility.

01:04:28

See, that cup and all they do.

01:04:31

This is also, I think, some Metal farming facility. Yeah.

01:04:37

So, foundry someone doing there. Pyrometer This is again, the yeah, this is again, the pyrometer.

01:04:41

this is rather the same. Go to. Pyrometer.

01:04:44

Sir, right side.

01:04:45

No, not that, this is done. No, not that, not that,

01:04:47

below, below, here, yeah.

01:04:49

No, no, third one. Someone pouring that's...

01:04:52

Professor Roshan developed a unique process

01:04:55

called fluid sand process,

01:04:57

where the sand doesn't need ramming and so on.

01:05:01

Okay. And he did it, oh god.

01:05:06

and, he did this thing, he patented it.

01:05:10

And, they, I think, they made,

01:05:12

I mean, they sold it to foundry also.

01:05:18

Good. They are all similar.

01:05:21

They are all similar. Similar equipment, go down. They are all similar equipment.

01:05:27

Maybe, that one. So, this is possibly, This

01:05:29

is in the Mechanical Metallurgy department, shank Okay.

01:05:35

Okay. These are, you know, we do fatigue testing,

01:05:38

in a unidirectional... Okay.

01:05:40

These are all machines for bidirectional fatigue testing.

01:05:43

You can test the, an industrial component.

01:05:46

Okay. They had one smaller shank and bigger shank.

01:05:49

For a long time, we had difficulty in putting it into operation,

01:05:53

but finally, Germans as usual,

01:05:56

took it upon themselves and set it right

01:05:58

and made it functional. Very good.

01:06:04

This is an ordinary tensiometer. Yeah, tensiometer.

01:06:08

Tensile testing of a small sample.

01:06:10

Come down, there is a microscope.

01:06:12

This is the Zeiss microscope. Old. Zeiss

01:06:15

microscope. In fact, my old friend, he asked me

01:06:19

if this microscope is for sale, he will take it

01:06:21

as a museum piece for his factory. Yeah.

01:06:25

We all used to use it, it had projection facilities,

01:06:28

but later, I am told, it was refurbished

01:06:30

and it is working well. And now, we have very good ones.

01:06:36

Some meeting there?

01:06:40

That, I don't know.

01:06:42

That is E. G. Ramachandran.

01:06:44

See, how was young he is. The one is, in the centre, sir?

01:06:46

Centre, I do not know.

01:06:47

This is Srinivas Raghavan. That is Vasudevan, all young,

01:06:52

Very young. unbelievably young.

01:06:55

I would like to have this photo.

01:06:58

Okay. E. G. would love to have it.

01:07:00

Okay. Of course, too late in life.

01:07:06

This is again, this is an induction melting unit. Okay.

01:07:11

We had it, we used to melt a lot.

01:07:13

Professor Srikanta Kumarswami used to be in charge.

01:07:18

All kinds of alloys he used to,

01:07:20

he was specially brought in

01:07:22

for his practical knowledge for melting. Correct.

01:07:24

Melting, melting. Yeah. Even though, he is theoretically, he was, he had not studied.

01:07:27

People talk a lot about. E. G. R. specially brought him,

01:07:29

Steel making. Melting. so that melting can be done

01:07:31

for various researches.

01:07:33

He was working in Bhadravathi steel plant earlier.

01:07:38

Yeah. So, Chemistry lab. And, this is our Chemical Testing Laboratory.

01:07:42

We used to have a call, we used to

01:07:44

have a lab called Metallurgical Analysis Lab.

01:07:49

Maybe ore dressing. And, this is a regular microscope, Microscope.

01:07:55

they are counting.

01:08:00

That is Professor E. G. Ramachandran.

01:08:05

That is, I think, a politician.

01:08:07

Narasimharaya? No, no, no.

01:08:12

R. Natarajan you can see there, who passed away recently.

01:08:18

Convocation day. These are all various samples,

01:08:22

metal forming samples.

01:08:26

You can go to that one, this is... This is the convocation.

01:08:32

Who is the chief guest?

01:08:35

Chief guest, can you guess?

01:08:38

Sampath, Koch is there, Varghese, Sethunathan.

01:08:46

Professor Ramasastry. Yeah, if you tell me the chief guest,

01:08:50

I can tell you. Mr. Koch also is there in the...

01:08:52

Koch is there. You mentioned about Scheer.

01:08:55

Yeah, Scheer. Believe me, the whole Ebert, all those people seem to be there, sir.

01:08:59

campus was flooded with Germans.

01:09:03

yeah yeah yeah. We were fortunate.

01:09:06

N. V. C. Swamy is there, Professor Sastry is there.

01:09:14

As I said, Professor Sampath is there. Professor Sampath is there.

01:09:17

Really giants, I mean.

01:09:19

Incidentally, Professor Sampath's brother

01:09:21

was my guide, Professor Ranganathan.

01:09:23

Yes. I know very well, I know very well, I too know him quite well.

01:09:29

And, you mentioned about Professor C. V. Raman

01:09:32

teaching Professor E. G. R.

01:09:35

So, that way, you know, Professor E. G. R.

01:09:36

taught Professor Anantharaman,

01:09:37

Anantharaman taught Professor Ranganathan,

01:09:39

and he taught me.

01:09:40

And professor. Professor So, I am like a 5th generation connected.

01:09:43

Anantharaman also, I know very well.

01:09:45

Yeah, can you just go back,

01:09:46

he wanted to see one of them.

01:09:50

Sir, this one, yeah which is not so much here, no over.

01:09:57

The last one. Roshan, Roshan had some

01:10:01

Equipment. equipments

01:10:04

That was. This one. This is actually something which I share.

01:10:09

Okay, okay. We both took a patent on that.

01:10:12

Excellent. Okay.

01:10:13

Professor E. G. Ramachandran, Roshan and myself. Excellent.

01:10:16

This is actually some instrument I was using.

01:10:18

Ok. I wanted to use it further,

01:10:20

then, Professor Ramachandran said, "why not we patent it?

01:10:23

Collaborate and patent this. So, that is one of our

01:10:25

patents. We have a process called shell moulding.

01:10:29

And, the shell temperature has to be kept at

01:10:31

260 to 280 degree centigrade.

01:10:34

Okay. Otherwise, the moulds will be charred,

01:10:36

otherwise, it will be under baked.

01:10:39

For that, they, that time, we didn't have

01:10:40

IR cameras and all that.

01:10:42

So, this is contact eye. So, we used to use contact eye.

01:10:45

Roshan took a number of patents

01:10:47

and he was industrially very active.

01:10:51

Right. Yeah, This is the genesis of...

01:10:54

because general... Thank you, Professor

01:10:56

Professor Prabhakar. Wonderful. Thank you, thank you.